EP 112: Designing Careful and Kind Care | Dominique Allwood

How can revolt against industrialized healthcare? Can we design careful and kind care?

Dr. Dominique Allwood is a healthcare leader with almost 20 years of experience working as a medical doctor and public health physician in healthcare in the UK. She enjoys variety and juggling multiple roles and is currently Chief Medical Officer of UCLPartners, a health innovation partnership across a population of 5.2 million people, and Director of Population Health at Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, at a large teaching hospital in London. She is interested in a range of areas including improving equity, population health, anchor institutions, accelerating net zero in healthcare, clinical engagement, and quality improvement. She has worked extensively across healthcare in delivery, leadership, management and advisory roles for provider and commissioner organisations, academic institutions, national policy bodies, management consultancy, charities and think tanks. She holds an MPH, has previously undertaken a Darzi Fellowship in Clinical Leadership, and is an Associate Editor for BMJ Leader Journal. She is a Governor of University College Hospital and a Board member of The

Patient Revolution in the US. She was previously named a Rising Star in the Health Services Journal and shortlisted for a prestigious national mentoring award. She is currently completing an MBA at Henley Business School.

Episode mentions and links:

Careful, kind care is our compass out of the pandemic fog

Taking one step further: five equity principles for hospitals to increase their value as anchor institutions

Restaurant Dominique would take you to: Lefteris O Politis

Bonus: This is Athens: A beginners guide to souvlaki

Follow Dominique: LinkedIn | Twitter 

Episode Reflection

This week’s episode with Dr. Allwood was like therapy for me. For those of us who obsess over the design of care and the pursuit of more human-centered systems, it often feels like a Sisyphean task. So when you have the opportunity to hear from someone who just gets it, who had lived the struggle and is pushing that same boulder, it makes the task feel just a little bit lighter. Dominique had a lot of awesome takes on how we can begin to better understand our broken systems and what we can do to change them. So, if you haven’t yet, go listen to that episode right now! For my reflection, I wanted to turn to the mentioned article which was co-written by Dominique and one of our previous guests and favorite people, Victor Montori. Of course, we have to start by talking about the soul-shattering quote from the article that Bon quoted in the episode.

“Relentlessly pursued, however, industrialised healthcare turns patients into widgets and clinicians into production line workers, the work of caring reduced to processing people through the system. Industrial healthcare has exhausted care givers and patients, and morally injured, burned out, and spent clinicians, making it humanly unsustainable.”

I mean, honestly, there is not much to say about this other than it’s probably the best and most succinct description of what is wrong with healthcare today. The challenge we all face is what to do about it. Do we rebel as caregivers? As patients do we demand change? Haven’t we already tried those things and gotten nowhere? I think we need more of what The Patient Revolution is doing. We need full-on revolt, from all parties, on all sides.

On to the next painfully resonant quote.

“Covid-19 and its pandemic fog arrived as industrialised healthcare was reaching its apogee. A “new normal” was heralded beyond the covid-19 pandemic, but no threshold or dawn has become apparent in the transition from the pandemic to the post-pandemic world. Instead of a before and an after, a thick fog now envelops and disorients patients and healthcare professionals.”

I mean, damn, the fog. We’ve all heard of covid fog, that foggy, tired feeling that many have and continue to experience after getting covid-19. But the idea that fog now envelopes the whole system and everyone in it is EXACTLY how it feels. Something has happened to our clarity of vision. The crystal clear mission drive that led us to become caregivers in the first place almost feels like a dream today. It’s like we were kids and suddenly uncle covid came over for the holidays and told us that there was no such thing as magic and it was our parents leaving money under our pillow all along. Or maybe it’s better to liken it to the fog of war, we’ve come home, but we’ll never be the same. On the bright side, burnout and wellness are being taken seriously, maybe for the first time ever, in healthcare. As previous podcast guest Rick Griffith said, we must be optimistic because we have to do this, we have to move forward, and we are creating the system right now that will either perpetuate or solve these ills. 

Now for something a little more positive.

What are the antidotes to industrialized healthcare? Dominque also discussed the following manifestations in this week’s episode. They are, “hurry”, “blur”, “burden”, and “cruelty.” Dominique described the antidote to “blur” being, “seeing patients in high-definition” and the “shift away from saying what’s the matter with you to what matters to you.” I would imagine the antidote to “hurry” is to slow down. It’s artisan and personal. This brings me back to Episode 106 with Joanne Cheung where we discussed the problems with the term “care delivery,” likening it to getting a quick bite delivered to you versus sitting down for a slow, handcrafted meal with family. What would you call the antidote to burden? Maybe ease, calmness, or relief? Despite all the technology at our fingertips, getting and providing care continues to be a burdensome task. More tech, more problems. And then there is kindness, the antidote for cruelty. Can we really rely on the kindness of individuals to put “care” in healthcare? NO! Not when we are working within systems that perpetuate cruelty. We need a kinder system all around! 

That’s all I got for now. I hope you enjoyed this week’s “therapy session” as much as I did. Thanks, Dr. Allwood, for leading the way to re-humanize health.

Written by Rob Pugliese

Excerpts from: Montori V M, Allwood D. Careful, kind care is our compass out of the pandemic fog BMJ 2022; 379 :e073444 doi:10.1136/bmj-2022-073444

Previous
Previous

EP 113: Designing a Good Death | Sunita Puri

Next
Next

EP 111: Designing Sh*t | Saffron Cassaday